This show should never have been longer than 15 or 16 episodes (sometimes I even think that there should be a law against school romcoms with more than 26 episodes). Its main character, who was the most important asset of this anime when it just came out, also turned out to be its biggest weakness now. In the first season Hikigaya stood out among the army of Ordinary High School Student protagonists because of his sort of misanthropy. But, unfortunately for us, he found friends and his place in society in the same first season. That was way too fast! He wasn’t unique anymore — yeah, one can argue that he was still a creep but it didn’t feel natural, it was kind of “yeah, yeah, let’s pretend that you’re still that loner as you were at the beginning — but we’re still friends and you’re going to save no matter what, right?”
In addition to the changes to Hikigaya’s personality and relationships, I personally can’t stand how overly dramatic such events as, for instance, a cultural festival are shown. It’s not just a school festival, no! Everything is a matter of life and death, every decision can lead to either a triumph or miserable and dishonorable defeat! It’s a prom dammit, not the Second Impact!
Also I have to mention the shameless coffee advertisement throughout the show. It’s not terrible but certainly noticeable. The heroes are going home? They are drinking some-particular-brand of coffee. They are having a long vague and full of innuendos conversation — you simply can’t do it without checking out whether a vending machine nearby has your favorite coffee.
The silver lining is that there’s still Yukinoshita. She’s super cute and a few minutes with her in the last two episodes sort of redeem for whatever we saw before (no one will remember that anyway). We have a second to none confession scene in episode 11 and an omega cute date in the last episode, I am ready to forgive this anime for everything… but here comes an awkward dance with the teacher and their inevitable and embarrassing fall.
Long story short — this anime had good potential but didn’t live up to it. Lucky I am though that my memory is terrible — all the boring stuff will be forgotten quickly and I will remember My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU by the moments like this ^_^
