Even though the first season of Promised Neverland wasn’t flawless I enjoyed it a lot and was genuinely curious what’s going to happen next. It was obvious that we’d get a sequel, but because it still was a matter of “when” — I bought and read a couple of volumes of the original manga. Confession time — I didn’t especially like where the story was headed and still pretty sure that even if the second season had followed the source material closely it still would’ve resulted in an average show. Nonetheless, what we did get was a hot mess.
Yakusoku No Neverland 2 consists of a bunch of plot devices barely attached to each other with scotch tape. The kids are attacked by monsters? Good guys show up in time to save the day. They are running away from the armed squads sent by the farms? No worries, something will get in the way. Miraculous drug? Check. Miraculous anti-drug? Check. Need to get back to the farm? Oh, we accidentally have all the blueprints and whatnot. The main character is dying? Weeeell… it’s becoming awkward but ughh… we have a cure. There’s no logic behind events in this anime, everything just happens.
The entire utopic idea of “demons and humans should be friends, actually it’s just been a huge 1000-year long misunderstanding or an Evil Scheme of the Evil Demon Nobles, and if we just hug each other and talk everything over — it’ll solve all the problems in no time”, promoted by Emma and silently supported by pretty much all other characters, is laughable. Yet, it’s the main plan. Which somehow succeeded because why not? Sonju mentions that whereas he doesn’t eat kids from the farms he’d want to hunt and eat those who’d live “in the wild” — let’s just forget about this, he’s a good guy in our books, we shouldn’t complicate things too much. Everything related to the characters or plot in the second season is dumbed down.
Again, I read a couple of volumes of the manga and skimmed the rest of the original plot, and I find it’s hard to believe that it would’ve been a masterpiece but this anime, the anime I can’t recall a single strong, emotional, memorable scene from, was definitely a let-down. The only silver lining I can think of is that we won’t need to wait for another season anymore =)
